Health1 min read

While the headlines rave about Milburn’s Neets review, the young people I know are angry and frustrated | Felicity Halstead

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Milburn review outlines guarantees for education, apprenticeships, and employment, alongside financial incentives like youth job grants and targeted employer national insurance cuts for retail and hospitality. However, critics warn these proposals fail to rapidly generate high-quality careers or accommodate the 15% of Neets who hold university degrees. Long-term progress remains uncertain because smaller enterprises still require robust state assistance to provide essential pastoral care and on-the-job training.

Key points

  • Proposed cuts to employer national insurance contributions risk restricting early career…: Proposed cuts to employer national insurance contributions risk restricting early career options by initially focusing solely on retail and hospitality.
  • Current state support mechanisms rarely align with the specific career ambitions held by…: Current state support mechanisms rarely align with the specific career ambitions held by unemployed young people.
  • Smaller enterprises require additional assistance with pastoral care and training to ensu…: Smaller enterprises require additional assistance with pastoral care and training to ensure long-term job placements succeed.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

I was at my desk last Thursday morning as a steady stream of young people filed into GoodWork’s central London community hub for a day of employability workshops. Despite the accusations of disengagement among young people, they didn’t need me to tell them that proposals to cut some benefits for under-25s were all over the news. I could hear them talking about it as soon as the lift pinged open – and the mood was low.

Alan Milburn has made a concerted effort to say that he doesn’t believe young people are to blame for dire levels of youth unemployment. He says the system has let them down and only a decade-long transformation will fix a problem that is complex and deeply entrenched. Simply recognising the scale of the problem and being willing to invest in a solution is a positive start.

But what I’ve heard from young people is frustration that their struggles in the job market are framed primarily through a need to reform the welfare system. They hear a lot about their responsibilities and benefit entitlements, but…

Health