Health1 min read

STAT+: UnitedHealth sues to reverse downgraded Medicare Advantage quality scores

By · Via STAT Health · Published by Everything Blog

In short

UnitedHealth Group has filed suit against the federal government over downgraded quality star ratings for next year. The healthcare giant covers more than 9 million individuals, marking it as at least the 15th plan to challenge the calculations made by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Federal regulators score plans on a one-to-five scale evaluating health screens, member satisfaction, and additional metrics, with ratings of four stars or higher conferring critical financial bonuses. The insurers argue that the methodology used by regulators is inconsistent and deprives plans of the bonuses they are owed.

Key points

  • Achieving a rating of four or more stars is necessary for Medicare Advantage plans to rec…: Achieving a rating of four or more stars is necessary for Medicare Advantage plans to receive lucrative government bonus payments.
  • Insurers argue in court that federal rating formulas are inconsistent and unfairly lower…: Insurers argue in court that federal rating formulas are inconsistent and unfairly lower plan scores below vital bonus thresholds.
  • The mounting legal battle against federal regulators unfolds as the critical Dec. 7 annua…: The mounting legal battle against federal regulators unfolds as the critical Dec. 7 annual Medicare enrollment deadline rapidly approaches.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

UnitedHealth Group has sued the federal government over its lowered Medicare Advantage star ratings for next year, further plunging the program’s ratings system into disarray.

UnitedHealth marks at least the 15th Medicare Advantage plan to file a lawsuit against the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services for how the agency calculated 2027 star ratings. UnitedHealth is also the largest Medicare Advantage insurer, covering more than 9 million people. Medicare’s annual enrollment period ends Dec. 7.

The government rates Medicare Advantage plans on a scale from one to five stars, based on health screens, customer satisfaction, and other measures that get mixed into a complicated formula. Those with at least four stars earn bonus money. The insurers argue in their lawsuits that the government’s measurement is inconsistent and is inappropriately dropping their scores below the bonus thresholds.

This article is exclusive to STAT+ subscribers

Unlock this article — plus daily market-moving biopharma analysis — by subscribing to STAT+.

Already have an account? Log in

Health