Business1 min read

Man wins Rs 1.78L claim against Max Bupa after insurer rejects hospital bill

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission ruled in favor of Dhamtari resident Bholanath Agrawal following the rejection of his medical expenses from a December 2018 hospitalization. Max Bupa had refused cashless clearance and dismissed the reimbursement by alleging Agrawal concealed his hypertension, diabetes, and past bypass surgery. However, the commission cited Supreme Court precedent, noting the company possessed medical and pathology reports prior to policy issuance. Consequently, the insurer's conduct was deemed a deficiency in service and an unfair trade practice.

Key points

  • Insurers cannot repudiate medical claims for non-disclosure when they were provided patho…: Insurers cannot repudiate medical claims for non-disclosure when they were provided pathology and medical records prior to policy issuance.
  • The consumer commission classified the unsubstantiated denial of the policyholder's treat…: The consumer commission classified the unsubstantiated denial of the policyholder's treatment claim as an unfair trade practice.
  • Companies must conclusively establish deliberate concealment of material facts to lawfull…: Companies must conclusively establish deliberate concealment of material facts to lawfully reject valid policy benefits under consumer law.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

RAIPUR: Holding an insurance company guilty of deficiency in service for rejecting a policyholder’s medical insurance claim, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Raipur, has directed the insurer to reimburse Rs 1,78,295 spent on medical treatment, besides paying compensation of Rs 10,000 for mental agony and Rs 5,000 towards litigation expenses.

The commission held that the insurance company could not subsequently rely on the alleged non-disclosure of medical conditions without establishing that the policyholder had concealed material information.

Referring to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Om Prakash Agrawal versus Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd., the commission observed that an insurer cannot reject a claim merely by alleging suppression of a pre-existing disease without establishing the relevant facts.

The commission held that the insurer's conduct amounted to deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.

The commission, comprising president Prashant Kundu and member Dr Anand Verma, passed the order on Nov 3, in a complaint filed by Bholanath Agrawal, a resident of Dhamtari district, against Max Bupa Health Insurance Company Ltd.

According to the complaint, Agrawal and his…

Business