Business1 min read

Rs 2,429 sandals fail on first use; Gurgaon couple wins refund and Rs 26k costs

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Deepak Gupta and his wife purchased the footwear from a Gurudwara Road showroom, but the heel bent and adhesive detached during the very first wear. Despite the damage occurring two days after purchase, the retailer refused a refund or replacement, citing an invoice clause that limited remedies to repairs under a 90-day warranty. The consumer commission dismissed this defense, finding the merchant guilty of unfair trade practices and deficiency in service. Consequently, the store must return the full purchase price with interest while covering substantial financial damages.

Key points

  • The consumer commission ruled that unilateral invoice terms cannot override established s…: The consumer commission ruled that unilateral invoice terms cannot override established statutory consumer protections.
  • The retailer was ordered to refund the purchase amount of Rs 2,428.99 with 9% annual inte…: The retailer was ordered to refund the purchase amount of Rs 2,428.99 with 9% annual interest from the purchase date.
  • The forum awarded Rs 15,000 for mental harassment alongside Rs 11,000 to cover the couple…: The forum awarded Rs 15,000 for mental harassment alongside Rs 11,000 to cover the couple's litigation expenses.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

GURGAON: A pair of sandals bought for Rs 2,429 developed a defect on its first use, but when the buyers approached the showroom, they were offered repairs instead of a replacement. Rejecting the footwear company’s repair-only warranty policy, the Gurgaon consumer commission has ordered it to refund the purchase price and pay Rs 26,000 in compensation and litigation costs.

Deepak Gupta and his wife Shweta bought the sandals from Stelatoes Shoes & Accessories Pvt Ltd’s Gurudwara Road showroom on Aug 30, 2025. The salesperson allegedly assured them that the footwear was a fresh piece and carried a six-month replacement warranty in case of any defect.

However, when Shweta wore the sandals for the first time on Sept 1, the heel bent and the adhesive came loose, the couple alleged. They returned to the showroom on Sept 3, but the manager allegedly blamed the damage on her twisting her foot and refused to replace the footwear, offering only repairs.

After their repeated requests for a refund went unanswered, the couple approached the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission.

Advocate Chandan Yadav, representing…

Business