Politics1 min read

Mahmood infuriates fellow ministers by failing to reveal impact of UK migration shake-up

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The controversial asylum reforms include ending permanent leave to remain and stripping the government of its statutory duty to support destitute individuals. While a Home Office assessment acknowledged risks of rising rough sleeping, department officials maintain that relocating asylum seekers out of hotels will not cause homelessness. Housing Secretary Angela Rayner is pressing for comprehensive impact data, warning that moving migrants into houses of multiple occupancy could spark anti-immigration demonstrations. Rayner is also fighting to exempt the care sector from planned legal migration curbs to prevent severe staffing shortages.

Key points

  • Home Office ministers must negotiate compromises across government to resolve internal di…: Home Office ministers must negotiate compromises across government to resolve internal disputes regarding homelessness and care staffing.
  • Internal critics suspect the Home Office is deliberately hiding data to conceal the true…: Internal critics suspect the Home Office is deliberately hiding data to conceal the true scale of community disruption.
  • Cabinet members fear the unquantified asylum policies will directly clash with the prime…: Cabinet members fear the unquantified asylum policies will directly clash with the prime minister's ambitious rough sleeping commitments.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Shabana Mahmood has infuriated ministerial colleagues by failing to share what they see as crucial information about the impact of her migration changes.

Sources say the home secretary has repeatedly refused to reveal how much she expects homelessness to rise as a result of changes to the asylum system.

Home Office ministers will meet their counterparts from other departments over the next few days to thrash out a compromise amid warnings about a potential staff crisis in the care sector.

One person with knowledge of the standoff said: “Shabana has been asked on multiple occasions what the Home Office assessment was of the impact her changes would have on homelessness and community cohesion, but she point-blank refused to engage with it.”

Allies of Mahmood say they cannot quantify the exact impact of the proposals because the detail has not yet been finalised. They insist the new system will be designed to minimise any impact on destitution and homelessness.

However, others in government believe the Home Office could give out more detailed information but does not want to admit how much…

Politics