Politics1 min read

Lula's victory alone cannot loosen the US and Israeli grip on Latin America

By · Via Middle East Eye · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva defeated Senator Flavio Bolsonaro by under four percentage points, becoming the first democratically elected Brazilian president to win a fourth term. The outcome mirrored deep geographic and ideological divides, with both contenders recording rejection rates between 45 and 46 percent before the vote. Despite international optimism on the left, earlier precedents like Argentina's Alberto Fernandez demonstrate how regional leaders often must maintain ties with Israel and the United States during debt talks with the International Monetary Fund. Furthermore, the victory exposes persistent succession issues within the Workers' Party, which has continued to rely on Lula…

Key points

  • External economic pressures and past diplomatic engagements with Washington and Israel co…: External economic pressures and past diplomatic engagements with Washington and Israel continue to limit the Latin American left's autonomy.
  • The Workers' Party faces persistent succession challenges after repeatedly depending on L…: The Workers' Party faces persistent succession challenges after repeatedly depending on Lula following major political setbacks since 2016.
  • Brazil remains sharply polarized domestically despite Lula achieving a historic fourth pr…: Brazil remains sharply polarized domestically despite Lula achieving a historic fourth presidential victory from behind in the first round.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

"Lula won! Lula won!" a Brazilian student shouted at a language school in Cairo. An Argentine activist sent a similar message. A pan-Arab news channel filled the screen with images of packed streets in Sao Paulo.

The excitement over Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva's fourth term is real, and it is shared by his supporters at home and by progressives across neighbouring countries. It is also exaggerated, especially when paired with hopes of a regional swing to the left and a distancing from the US and Israel.

Argentina, the homeland of exaggeration, offers a quick example.

After Alberto Fernandez defeated incumbent Mauricio Macri in 2019, a jubilant Peronist movement began imagining a regional realignment.

A Trotskyist activist from the southern suburbs of Buenos Aires captured the mood: "We already have AMLO [Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador] in Mexico, and now we must go for Brazil. Can you imagine Lula being re-elected? Latin America would be leftist once again!"

New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch

Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other…

Politics