Politics1 min read

How "Safety" Rhetoric Is Weaponized to Protect Israel and Smear Its Critics

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

An analysis of ten prominent U.S. news organizations found that terms concerning Jewish safety appeared 254 times over three years, while Muslim or Arab safety appeared only six times. This media gap exists alongside documented surges in anti-Muslim bias, including 8,061 incidents logged by advocacy groups in the half-year after October 7, 2023. At the same time, violent physical assaults against Muslim and Palestinian students were recorded in Vermont and at major universities such as UCLA, Stanford, and the University of Texas. The selective emphasis on antisemitism serves to justify broader security measures while eroding academic freedom on college campuses.

Key points

  • Disproportionate media coverage obscures equivalent or greater levels of campus fear repo…: Disproportionate media coverage obscures equivalent or greater levels of campus fear reported by Muslim students.
  • Elevated focus on specific safety rhetoric is actively leveraged to suppress free speech…: Elevated focus on specific safety rhetoric is actively leveraged to suppress free speech and academic freedom.
  • The selective narrative deprioritizes documented violence and bigotry directed against Mu…: The selective narrative deprioritizes documented violence and bigotry directed against Muslim and Arab Americans.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Who is deserving of “safety” and who isn’t? Which violent threats—real or perceived—are given 22-point-font headlines, breathless coverage, and elevated from a mere news item or box checking exercise to a moral emergency in urgent need of government spending, countless media hits, grilling of candidates and politicians, sympathetic profiles of victims, and crackdowns on Free Speech?

In the context of the past three years, where “Jewish safety” has been used as a blunt instrument to silence criticism of Israel and criminalize speech, clearly one group, that of Jewish-Americans, has systematically been given priority over Muslim and Arab-Americans. Or at least, the alleged safety of Jewish-Americans, given that this narrative has little bearing on the real threats facing Jews in the United States.

A survey of the 10 most popular media outlets in the United States (New York Times, Washington Post, USAToday, Politico, ABC News, NBC News, CBS News, CNN.com and CNN cable news and MSNBC/MSNOW) shows that “Jewish safety” and its variants have been mentioned roughly 42 times more than “Muslim/Arab safety” and its variants—at 254 mentions versus 6, over…

Politics