Business1 min read

Xiaomi, Flextronics hid royalty deals: Govt

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Indian government has accused Xiaomi and Flextronics Technologies India of masking licensing agreements to improperly reduce import taxes over a three-year period prior to 2020. Officials argued in September court filings that Flex failed to reveal contractual structures, while Xiaomi only disclosed licensing deals after investigations commenced. Both companies maintain that royalty fees should remain separate from component valuations. The dispute intensifies legal headwinds for Xiaomi, which already faces a recommended probe by India's Serious Fraud Investigation Office.

Key points

  • The Indian government asserts that Flextronics is liable for not presenting its manufactu…: The Indian government asserts that Flextronics is liable for not presenting its manufacturing agreements to customs officials.
  • Xiaomi and Flex argue that component purchases and technology partner royalties are separ…: Xiaomi and Flex argue that component purchases and technology partner royalties are separate transactions that do not undervalue imports.
  • Legal experts caution that a government victory could lead to similar tax scrutiny for ph…: Legal experts caution that a government victory could lead to similar tax scrutiny for pharmaceutical and automobile manufacturers.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

The dispute, which could cost Xiaomi's India unit more than $150 million, is seen as a test of how India views dealings between companies and their contract manufacturers, a sector which has attracted the likes of Foxconn, Jabil and Tata Electronics to expand their operations.

Also Read: India's Serious Fraud Office recommends 'detailed' probe into Xiaomi's business in country

Xiaomi, which holds about 12% of India's smartphone market, is facing multiple regulatory challenges. In addition to tax demands, India's Serious Fraud Investigation Office has proposed a probe into alleged irregularities in its business model, Reuters has reported. Xiaomi has not commented on the proposed investigation.

The royalty dispute stems from a Supreme Court challenge Xiaomi filed in January against an Indian tribunal ruling that found it had underpaid duties in three years before 2020 by excluding royalties paid to technology partners from the value of imported phone components.

Xiaomi holds the view that components are imported by its contract manufacturers, and royalty payments of 2-5% are separate and do not attract tariffs.

Also Read: Local partner wanted for Xiaomi ‘home’…

Business