Business1 min read

Woman wins Rs 4.9L from commission after insurer denies claim for rain-damaged goods

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The dispute originated when torrential rains on June 30, 2022, caused severe water damage to goods inside Kanika's shop, which held inventory coverage up to Rs 20 lakh. Despite the policyholder furnishing immediate photographic evidence alongside an email packet containing 31 supporting documents, the insurance firm classified the file as a "No Claim." A three-member bench rejected the insurer's defenses regarding address mismatches and alleged reporting delays, determining the carrier failed to substantiate its claims. The commission ordered the insurer to settle the loss while awarding additional monetary compensation for litigation and mental harassment.

Key points

  • Insurers cannot rely on unsubstantiated procedural claims to repudiate legitimate invento…: Insurers cannot rely on unsubstantiated procedural claims to repudiate legitimate inventory loss coverage following heavy rainfall.
  • Prompt submission of comprehensive photo, video, and documentary evidence proved vital in…: Prompt submission of comprehensive photo, video, and documentary evidence proved vital in establishing the policyholder's commercial claim.
  • The insurance company must comply with all payment directives within 30 days of receiving…: The insurance company must comply with all payment directives within 30 days of receiving the commission's official order.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

NEW DELHI: A consumer commission in Haryana has held National Insurance Company guilty of deficiency in service for closing a shop owner's insurance claim as 'No Claim' after heavy rain damaged her stock, despite her submitting documents detailing the loss. It directed the insurer to pay Rs 4.8 lakh with 9 percent annual interest, along with Rs 10,000 towards compensation and litigation costs.

Insurance company closes shop owner's rain damage claim

According to the commission order, Kanika, a 39-year-old shop owner from

Rohtak, had insured the stock in her shop with National Insurance Company under a policy valid from October 21, 2021, to October 20, 2022. The policy covered clothes, Jaipuri Thewa jewellery, Jaipuri suits and other stock worth up to Rs 20 lakh.

On June 30, 2022, heavy rain damaged the entire stock lying in her shop. The complainant said she immediately informed the insurance company's agent and shared photographs and videos of the damaged goods.

The insurer registered her claim and appointed a surveyor, Sunil Vashishth, to inspect the premises and assess the loss. The surveyor asked her…

Business