The ruling resolved a dispute stemming from a February 2024 traffic incident along Holland Road where a private-hire driver braked to avoid a car that stopped for a crossing bird. The passenger, Yvonne Chen Qianyun, claimed injuries resulted from excessive braking and an inadequate following distance. However, the court found the driver acted reasonably under emergency conditions, rejecting the passenger's arguments and ordering her to pay S$15,000 in costs. The proceedings also revealed that the claimant is currently involved in two other pending lawsuits concerning separate road collisions.
Key points
A motorist is not legally liable for passenger injuries when braking abruptly to manage a…: A motorist is not legally liable for passenger injuries when braking abruptly to manage an unexpected emergency hazard.
The court rejected claims of excessive braking, ruling that the driver acted entirely rea…: The court rejected claims of excessive braking, ruling that the driver acted entirely reasonably under the specific traffic conditions.
The claimant faces substantial cost orders while actively maintaining at least two other…: The claimant faces substantial cost orders while actively maintaining at least two other pending court actions over separate traffic collisions.
Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1
In dismissing the suit, the judge said the incident was caused by a chicken crossing the road and it was unfortunately "part of the vicissitudes of life".
SINGAPORE: A woman sued her private-hire driver for injuries sustained when he braked abruptly to avoid a collision after a chicken crossed the road, but lost and was ordered to pay costs of S$15,000 (US$11,628).
In dismissing the suit, the judge said the woman was "an innocent passenger" but the driver was not responsible for the incident.
Instead, it was caused by the chicken, which the woman identified as a jungle fowl and the driver described as a rooster.
The incident was unfortunately part of "the vicissitudes of life", the judge said in a judgment published on Wednesday (Nov 18).
He also noted that the claimant had at least two other court claims pending over separate accidents.
THE CASE
The claimant, Ms Yvonne Chen Qianyun, was travelling in a private-hire vehicle driven by Mr Tan Teng Kiat along Holland Road on Feb 19, 2024.
According to reporting by Al Jazeera’s James Bays, high-profile interactions among major world leaders at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit are drawing significant diplomatic scrutiny. The gathering of Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin, and Chinese President Xi Jinping has sparked debate over the broader international standing of Moscow. Analysts are weighing whether these engagements will generate meaningful global policy shifts or simply project an image of normalized relations.
According to reporting on the high-level diplomatic encounter, Donald Trump met with Russian President Vladimir Putin to address pressing international conflicts and bilateral ties between their two nations. The exchange took place just prior to Trump's planned diplomatic talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen. Russian officials indicated that the ongoing war in Ukraine remained the central focus throughout the conversation.
Convening alongside the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit at the lakeside Kylin Villa resort, the major power leaders face divergent geopolitical agendas despite comparisons of their gathering to the 1945 Yalta Conference. Smaller European and Asian economies have voiced apprehension that their interests could be compromised as the three nations navigate ongoing global conflicts. Analysts view concrete breakthroughs as unlikely given the fundamentally conflicting priorities brought to the table.