Other1 min read

Woman buys Hawaii plot for $22,500; developer builds $500k home without consent

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

California resident Annaleine Reynolds originally acquired her one-acre parcel at a 2018 county tax auction for approximately $22,500. Years later, Keaau Development Partnership hired PJ's Construction to build roughly a dozen residences and mistakenly built on Reynolds' land, subsequently suing her when she refused a land swap. A Hawaii County judge eventually ordered the complete removal of the unauthorized structure because the builders failed to conduct a proper property survey, leading to a comprehensive settlement in 2025.

Key points

  • Private property owners retain their legal rights even when developers attempt to force l…: Private property owners retain their legal rights even when developers attempt to force land swaps to correct building errors.
  • Developers and contractors assume significant financial and legal risks when they proceed…: Developers and contractors assume significant financial and legal risks when they proceed with residential construction without completing a property survey.
  • Multi-party property disputes involving contractors, architects, and developers can drag…: Multi-party property disputes involving contractors, architects, and developers can drag on for years before reaching a final settlement.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A piece of land bought at a county tax auction was supposed to be a quiet investment for a California woman, something she could make use of when the time was right. Instead, the property became the centre of an unexpected legal dispute after she discovered that a fully built house, valued at around $500,000, stood on the land she had purchased. Annaleine ‘Anne’ Reynolds had paid approximately $22,500 for the vacant Hawaiian plot in 2018. She was not living on the island when construction took place, and it was only in 2023 that she learnt someone had built a house on her property without her knowledge or permission. The dispute eventually went to court before being settled in 2025.

How a vacant $22,500 Hawaiian plot became the site of a $500,000 home

According to Fortune reports, Reynolds acquired the one-acre property in Hawaiian Paradise Park, a residential subdivision in the Puna district of Hawaii's Big Island, in 2018. The purchase was made through a county tax auction, where she secured the land for about $22,500. At the time, the…

Other