Technology1 min read

Without a lawsuit, Linux might not have happened

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The federal copyright fight between UNIX System Laboratories and Berkeley Software Design lasted nearly two years before settling in February 1994. During this era, BSD was technically preferable for networking due to its fully functional TCP/IP stack, while initial Linux releases entirely lacked network support. However, Torvalds designed his system as a simpler analogue to AT&T System V UNIX and Andy Tanenbaum's MINIX rather than a strict UNIX replica. Consequently, Linux established a massive global presence that today outpaces BSD in overall device count.

Key points

  • Protracted legal uncertainty surrounding the BSD codebase prevented it from bootstrapping…: Protracted legal uncertainty surrounding the BSD codebase prevented it from bootstrapping the early commercial internet.
  • BSD-derived software remains vital today across Apple platforms, Netflix media distributi…: BSD-derived software remains vital today across Apple platforms, Netflix media distribution servers, routers, and video game consoles.
  • Linux maintains the dominant global footprint by powering millions of Android mobile devi…: Linux maintains the dominant global footprint by powering millions of Android mobile devices, home routers running OpenWrt, and cloud virtual machines.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A post by Adam Conway on the XDA Developers website discusses the history of a lawsuit over the UNIX codebase. The lawsuit, UNIX System Laboratories v. Berkeley Software Design, ran from 20 April 1992 and settled on 4 February 1994.

The web article argues that if this lawsuit hadn’t taken place, Linux might not have become the world force that it is. The reasoning is that without legal concerns over the BSD codebase, we would have had access to free software in the Berkeley Software Distribution (BSD) UNIX tradition. This included a fully functional Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol (TCP/IP) stack and could have helped bootstrap the emerging, widespread Internet.

There are some problems with this line of reasoning. Linus Torvalds commenced his work on Linux in 1991 and clearly was interested in developing an operating system independent of the desire for something aligned with the UNIX model. The early releases didn’t have a functional network stack, it is true. So, compared head-to-head with BSD UNIX, there was a clear reason to prefer BSD.

However, Linux was, in some ways, a…

Technology