Other1 min read

Wisconsin couple wins $200k fence case, sues 33 neighbours for $1,350 each

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The conflict began in 2019 when the Nazcr Trac Property Owners Association enforced a 2001 covenant prohibiting all fences, prompting a federal lawsuit backed by Disability Rights Wisconsin. Although a 2022 injunction permitted the barrier and an agreement was reached in August 2024, 55 households have still not paid the mandated $1,350 charge. The collection dispute has sparked neighborhood friction, as contributing residents worry they may face extra financial liabilities to cover the shortfall.

Key points

  • Residents who failed to pay their assigned shares of the housing discrimination settlemen…: Residents who failed to pay their assigned shares of the housing discrimination settlement are facing individual lawsuits.
  • Subdivision members have expressed frustration over funding legal payouts resulting from…: Subdivision members have expressed frustration over funding legal payouts resulting from board decisions made without their direct input.
  • Homeowners who already remitted their payments are concerned about potential supplemental…: Homeowners who already remitted their payments are concerned about potential supplemental liabilities if the outstanding funds remain unpaid.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A backyard fence intended to protect five children has turned into a costly legal dispute in a Wisconsin neighbourhood, with a family now taking its homeowners association and dozens of residents back to court. Lisa and Michael Newman of De Pere, Wisconsin, secured a $200,000 settlement after their neighbourhood association refused to let them build a fence around their property. Now, nearly two years after the settlement, the couple is pursuing unpaid contributions from residents who have not paid their assigned share. The latest development was reported by Realtor dot com and NBC 26, which have followed the dispute since it first reached federal court. The original disagreement began in 2019, when the Newmans approached the Nazcr Trac Property Owners Association (NTPOA) seeking permission to install a fence around their backyard. The couple wanted a secure outdoor space where their five children, all diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, could play without the risk of wandering away.

Some of the children had additional medical complexities, and the family believed a fenced yard would make outdoor activities safer while allowing them greater…

Other