Politics1 min read

Why Milburn's Neets reforms will only save £200m a year by 2036

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The initiative revamps the benefits structure by introducing a Youth Allowance to replace Universal Credit for under-25s and an Additional Cost Allowance in place of Personal Independence Payments. To support this transition, the government would spend £5.8bn per year by 2036 on mental health support, hiring incentives, and job guarantees. While these measures are expected to generate £6bn annually through £3.6bn in welfare reductions and £2.4bn in tax revenues, the substantial program costs leave taxpayers with a modest net balance. Milburn has urged devolved administrations across Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland to join the initiative under shared national objectives.

Key points

  • Achieving higher youth employment will offset welfare payouts but requires massive front-…: Achieving higher youth employment will offset welfare payouts but requires massive front-loaded spending on support services.
  • By 2036, the projected £6bn in combined welfare savings and tax revenue will largely be c…: By 2036, the projected £6bn in combined welfare savings and tax revenue will largely be canceled out by £5.8bn in program expenses.
  • Milburn considers youth joblessness a UK-wide issue that requires coordinated participati…: Milburn considers youth joblessness a UK-wide issue that requires coordinated participation from Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

- Published

Alan Milburn's long-awaited plan to help young people who are neither learning nor earning promises to save money from the UK's welfare bill.

Milburn said he believes his proposed reforms, which would reduce benefits for some young people who are not in education, employment or training (Neets) but aim to get them jobs in the long run, could save as much as £13.8bn in welfare costs over the next 10 years.

But after the extra spending he has proposed for job guarantees from the government, hiring incentives for firms, and health and education support, his reforms are only projected to save £200m a year of taxpayers' money overall by 2036.

BBC Verify has taken a look through the numbers.

How many young people claim benefits?

Analysts have expressed concerns about the sharply rising number of young people claiming health and disability benefits in recent years.

The Milburn report estimates that around £8bn a year is currently being spent on benefits directly for young people through the welfare system, made up of £4.6bn on Universal Credit and £3.2bn on…

Politics