Politics1 min read

Why is Shabana Mahmood tackling ‘two-tier policing’ if she doesn’t believe it exists? | Gaby Hinsliff

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Gaby Hinsliff reports that Shabana Mahmood's upcoming code will restrict officers from displaying politicised symbols, including LGBTQ+ rainbow designs on police cars, and limit uniformed participation in controversial public events. The initiative responds directly to allegations of two-tier policing, a concept frequently championed by Reform UK and Nigel Farage. Hinsliff notes that Mahmood supported a legal ruling that prevented uniformed Northumbria Police officers from marching in Pride parades. Ultimately, the Home Secretary is directing forces to replace activist outreach with traditional community engagement, such as attending local residents' meetings.

Key points

  • According to Gaby Hinsliff, the government is attempting to address public anxieties abou…: According to Gaby Hinsliff, the government is attempting to address public anxieties about policing bias promoted by figures like Nigel Farage.
  • YouGov polling shows Britons are deeply split on policing, with over half believing Black…: YouGov polling shows Britons are deeply split on policing, with over half believing Black individuals receive differential treatment, primarily harsher.
  • The impartiality push follows systemic criticisms of British law enforcement, including L…: The impartiality push follows systemic criticisms of British law enforcement, including Louise Casey's review finding the Metropolitan Police institutionally homophobic and misogynistic.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Ten years ago this month, Stephen Port was convicted of the murders of four young gay men lured to their deaths via the dating app Grindr.

But it took another five years for their families to learn through an inquest what some had long suspected: that the Metropolitan police’s failure to link the murders quickly enough may have contributed to the later deaths, raising difficult questions over whether that would have happened if the victims were straight. The year after that, officers at Charing Cross station were caught WhatsApping each other rape jokes and insults like “fuck you bender”, contributing to Louise Casey’s conclusion in a review not long afterwards that the force was both institutionally homophobic and misogynistic.

There have been extremely good reasons for the decision many forces across Britain made to let uniformed police officers march openly at Pride events in recent years, rather than simply stewarding. It seemed a quick, tangible way of signalling that times have changed, that hate crimes will be taken seriously and that gay officers are welcome to serve or join. But…

Politics