Politics1 min read

Why is a South China Sea Code of Conduct still unfinished after decades of talks?

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Diplomatic talks trace back to 1995, but territorial friction has repeatedly hindered the completion of a binding maritime pact. Negotiators face significant stalemates over specific areas, including Vietnam's insistence on covering the Chinese-controlled Paracel Islands. Meanwhile, regular confrontations, such as water cannon deployments and resupply disruptions in Philippine waters, continue to exacerbate tensions among overlapping claimants.

Key points

  • Disagreements regarding legal bindingness and geographic boundaries remain fundamental ob…: Disagreements regarding legal bindingness and geographic boundaries remain fundamental obstacles to finalizing the agreement.
  • Friction between China and the Philippines has severely undermined trust through dangerou…: Friction between China and the Philippines has severely undermined trust through dangerous maneuvers and resupply disruptions.
  • Multiple Southeast Asian countries face overlapping territorial disputes with Beijing acr…: Multiple Southeast Asian countries face overlapping territorial disputes with Beijing across the resource-rich South China Sea.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Singapore is set to inherit negotiations for the long-delayed South China Sea Code of Conduct in 2027, with some of the toughest issues still unresolved.

SINGAPORE: After decades of efforts to establish rules for managing disputes in the South China Sea, ASEAN and China have yet to conclude negotiations on a code of conduct for the heavily contested waterway.

On Sunday (Nov 15), the first day of the ASEAN Leaders’ Summit in Manila, Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said about 80 per cent of the negotiating text had been provisionally agreed, but acknowledged that there was “no conclusion yet”.

Differing positions among ASEAN member states and China, as well as the time needed for negotiations, had prevented the agreement from being finalised this year, she said.

Experts CNA spoke to pointed to major sticking points, including the code’s geographical scope and whether it would be legally binding, that have proved difficult to overcome.

“There must be trust between the Southeast Asian claimants and China,” said Dr Ian Storey, principal fellow at the ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute. “In the case of the…

Politics