Artificial Intelligence1 min read

Why are good developers so wary of agentic development?

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

While code generation tools have improved considerably, veteran developers still worry about system boundaries and behavior during real-world failures. This persistent wariness reflects a demand for strict operational guardrails rather than a dismissal of automated coding assistants. To examine these dynamics, a recent Thoughtworks experiment tasked senior staff with guiding agents to develop an airline application entirely from autonomous code. That project reached 80 percent completion, requiring the engineers to trade manual coding for extensive whiteboard sessions focused on system architecture.

Key points

  • Organizations lack historical experience managing production infrastructure that has been…: Organizations lack historical experience managing production infrastructure that has been constructed entirely by autonomous agents rather than humans.
  • Experienced engineers continue to supply critical domain context and pattern recognition…: Experienced engineers continue to supply critical domain context and pattern recognition that automated agents cannot successfully replicate.
  • Implementing agentic development shifts human engineering effort away from manual syntax…: Implementing agentic development shifts human engineering effort away from manual syntax writing toward domain modeling and boundary definition.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

TL;DR

Good developers’ caution about agentic development comes from knowing that built isn’t the same as working in production.

I’ve been surprised by how many excellent developers have been hesitant to go all in on coding agents. These are people who usually try new ways of working before anyone else and in many cases invent new tools and practices that support building the application well. So why have we had so much reluctance?

The easy (lazy?) answer is that they love writing code, or they’re worried about their jobs. I’m sure that’s true for some people, some of the time. And I know it is true for some of the developers I talk to but I always felt there was something else, another fear hiding behind those obvious ones. When we put together the Technology Radar every six months I try to block out a chunk of time for us to do an open space. In September, a discussion we had on agentic development, which pushed it to its limits, finally helped me see clearly what that fear is.

Building…

Artificial Intelligence