Technology1 min read

Why 3dfx 1 cards had such a washed out color output?

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Systems from 3dfx and NeXT were designed to handle blending, coverage, and texture interpolation in a linear color space to maintain mathematical accuracy. This design backfired because human eyes perceive light non-linearly, requiring high bit depths that budget-friendly 5-bit or 6-bit consumer hardware could not supply. Additionally, game artists textured their assets using tools calibrated for standard non-linear displays, worsening the mismatch. Developers focused heavily on raw performance, leaving color fidelity and gamma correction largely unaddressed during the era of games like glQuake.

Key points

  • Prioritizing mathematical correctness over the realities of human visual perception resul…: Prioritizing mathematical correctness over the realities of human visual perception resulted in severely degraded visual fidelity for early 3D accelerators.
  • Low channel bit depths made linear color spaces impractical for consumer graphics cards,…: Low channel bit depths made linear color spaces impractical for consumer graphics cards, creating harsh intensity banding across darker image tones.
  • Developers during the glQuake era prioritized raw rendering performance over correcting t…: Developers during the glQuake era prioritized raw rendering performance over correcting the poorly understood gamma differences in their source assets.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Both NeXT and 3DFX tried to “do the right thing” with color spaces, and it wound up generally making them look worse than competing options. I didn’t really understand it properly until years later.

It is natural to think that a pixel with a value of 1.0 is emitting twice the photons as a pixel with a value of 0.5, so you can do the obvious linear math to calculate partial pixel coverage, blending a foreground over a background, or interpolating between colors in a texture.

If displays are “linear”, that is correct. NeXT and 3DFX were much closer to linear than other contemporary displays. NeXT had crossover from the deep graphics understanding at Pixar, and 3DFX had the SGI heritage. They did this intentionally.

If you have 10+ bits per channel like the professional rendering systems, linear displays are The Right Thing.

Unfortunately, NeXTStation Colors were 4 bits per channel and 3DFX was 5 or 6 bits per channel, and there… it was not the right thing.

Human eyes aren’t linear intensity sensors. We mostly register relative changes in…

Technology