Other1 min read

When you’re traduced, abused and gaslighted – believe me, Black History Month matters | Hugh Muir

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Debate over the observance persists as conservative critics demand color-blind history while progressives argue the designated month tokenizes Black history through commercialization. Advocates counter that focused visibility remains vital to combat a deteriorating racial climate exemplified by an 86% rise in racist abuse targeting National Health Service nurses. To conclude the current observance, an initiative by Guardian Opinion is documenting how Black British identity has transformed across four distinct generations.

Key points

  • Opponents on the political right argue the month should end in favor of color-blind histo…: Opponents on the political right argue the month should end in favor of color-blind history, while some progressives contend it isolates history that should be taught year-round.
  • Proponents maintain that focused recognition is crucial to withstand escalating public ho…: Proponents maintain that focused recognition is crucial to withstand escalating public hostility and targeted abuse directed at minority groups.
  • Guardian Opinion is concluding this year's observance by examining cross-generational per…: Guardian Opinion is concluding this year's observance by examining cross-generational perspectives on Black British identity spanning young adults, parents, and grandparents.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Pity Black History Month UK, assailed on all sides. Those on the right seek to end the celebration on the basis that it amounts to special treatment for a group that doesn’t deserve it. History should be colour-blind: society should not differentiate, they say. We are not racist, we just want fairness. But often, they are – and they really don’t.

On the other side of the argument are the progressives, notably minority progressives, who say the idea of a month to consider Black history is demeaning because it should already have a year-round place in our teaching and consciousness. There is a further view that any beneficial effect the month once had has been diluted by unimaginative repetition and commercially motivated virtue signalling. Players taking the knee in the Premier League? Been there, done that: yawn!

I have long taken the glass-half-full approach. The ideal would be for Black history to be incorporated into the social and educational culture – and perhaps one day it will be. But in the meantime, I’ll take a mandated, month-long focus on the…

Other