Politics1 min read

We shouldn’t ‘blindly’ believe allegations of violence against women, Queensland’s new DV minister said in resurfaced comments

By · Via The Guardian · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Amanda Stoker, who was elected to the Queensland parliament in 2024, argued in a 2023 opinion piece that evidence must be assessed rather than blindly believing allegations to protect innocent defendants. Advocates like Full Stop Australia CEO Karen Bevan warned that such rhetoric from leadership directly influences whether victim-survivors choose to report crimes to authorities. Although her office declined to address how these views align with victim-centric policies, a spokesperson pointed to Stoker's legal background and broader context. Queensland Police Service research confirms that false reporting of domestic and sexual violence remains exceptionally rare.

Key points

  • Victim support advocates fear ministerial skepticism regarding allegations will actively…: Victim support advocates fear ministerial skepticism regarding allegations will actively discourage abuse reporting.
  • The minister's office defended the resurfaced 2023 opinion piece by citing her legal back…: The minister's office defended the resurfaced 2023 opinion piece by citing her legal background and concern for procedural fairness.
  • Some community sector figures publicly welcomed the ministerial appointment despite priva…: Some community sector figures publicly welcomed the ministerial appointment despite private reservations among frontline workers.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Women’s safety advocates have raised concerns about the appointment of rightwing Queensland MP Amanda Stoker as the state’s minister for the prevention of domestic violence in light of her resurfaced statements that people should not “blindly” believe women who make allegations of violence.

Stoker, who was appointed to the role on Saturday, argued in a 2023 article that the recent push to believe complaints “rather than carefully assess[ing] relevant evidence” would harm innocent defendants.

The former federal senator, has repeatedly supported the rights of people accused of sexual assault and implied some were subject to “false allegations”.

Former Australian of the year Grace Tame, who in 2021 criticised Stoker’s appointment to the federal outer ministry, said the appointment was “disappointing”.

Stoker’s appointment this week was welcomed in public by some in the community sector. Guardian Australia has also spoken to several people who work in Queensland supporting victims of domestic and sexual violence who said they had private concerns about Stoker taking over the portfolio, which includes responsibility for the child safety system, after the resignation of Amanda Camm.

None…

Politics