Politics1 min read

Voter or candidate has no right to get a seat reserved, says SC

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The court issued the decision while dismissing a petition against a 2025 amendment to the Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis Act, 1961, which reset the rotation baseline for local elections. Petitioners argued that rebooting the cycle overlooked earlier seat history and unfairly altered reservation patterns in existing territories. The bench concluded the overall proportion of reserved seats remained constitutionally compliant, though it granted the petitioners permission to submit their concerns directly to administrative authorities.

Key points

  • Neither individual voters nor aspiring candidates possess an enforceable legal right to c…: Neither individual voters nor aspiring candidates possess an enforceable legal right to claim a designated reserved seat.
  • Electoral reservation policies are constitutionally sound as long as total seat numbers r…: Electoral reservation policies are constitutionally sound as long as total seat numbers reflect community population proportions.
  • Petitioners retain the ability to submit administrative representations to appropriate au…: Petitioners retain the ability to submit administrative representations to appropriate authorities despite the court dismissal.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

The bench allowed the petitioners to ask the appropriate authority to consider their representations.

NEW DELHI: Supreme Court Monday said no voter or candidate had a right to demand reservation of a particular constituency for the SC/ST community, and govt's decision to reserve a constituency could not be questioned if the number of reserved constituencies was proportionate to these communities' population.The petitioners had challenged govt's 2025 amendment to Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis Act, 1961. The amendment said the next general election would be treated as the starting point for rotating constituencies reserved for SC/ST communities.They alleged this wiped out the history of previous rotations and meant some constituencies that should have been reserved based on the earlier cycle would not be reserved.Advocate Vipin Sanghi said, "Introduction of a new set of rules, by itself, cannot furnish an independent justification for disregarding the previous rotation cycle where relevant electoral territories substantially continue to exist, albeit with altered boundaries, areas or numerical designations,"

A bench of Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana asked, "Do voters or candidates have a right to…

Politics