Other1 min read

Unpermitted dam repair floods neighbour's pond; court upholds $554,294 award

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Robert Shawn Noecker suffered significant land damage when an earthen dam failed in October 2017 after Bernhart attempted unpermitted repairs using a backhoe shovel. The breach released approximately 40 years of accumulated sediment that completely filled Noecker's upper pond and threatened a lower one. Additionally, Bernhart had dug unapproved artificial drainage ditches that overwhelmed Noecker's retention pump and left standing water near his workshop. In affirming the substantial judgment, the appeals court granted legal fees and instructed the trial court to consider added emotional distress awards.

Key points

  • The Washington Court of Appeals affirmed a $554,294 trespass and nuisance judgment agains…: The Washington Court of Appeals affirmed a $554,294 trespass and nuisance judgment against Craig Bernhart for the property flooding.
  • The trial court must now consider whether to grant additional financial damages to Robert…: The trial court must now consider whether to grant additional financial damages to Robert Shawn Noecker for emotional distress.
  • Property owners face full legal liability when unpermitted, substandard excavation work a…: Property owners face full legal liability when unpermitted, substandard excavation work artificially redirects water and causes substantial harm to neighbors.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A landowner in Washington state carried out repairs on a dam without obtaining the required permit or consulting an engineer. When the dam failed months later, water and decades of accumulated sediment rushed onto a neighbour's property, filling one pond and damaging another. Nearly nine years after the work, an appeals court has upheld a judgment awarding the neighbour more than $554,000 for trespass and nuisance.

The dispute involved Robert Shawn Noecker and the owners of an adjoining property in Bothell, Washington. On November 16, the Washington Court of Appeals, Division One, affirmed the trial court's findings that the dam work and separate drainage alterations had caused unlawful damage to Noecker's land.

The court also sent the case back to the lower court to consider whether Noecker should receive additional compensation for emotional distress. It awarded him reasonable attorney fees and costs for the appeal.

How the dam failure damaged the neighbouring property

According to the court's opinion available

online, the dam had been built in 1981 by a previous owner of the Bernhart property, under a permit from the…

Other