Technology1 min read

UK tribunal confirms government order demanding access to Apple data

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The legal fight escalated after Britain issued a revised order in July focused strictly on accessing encrypted data for its domestic users. An earlier January notice targeting both American and British cloud backups had been abandoned following extensive talks with the Trump administration. Civil rights groups Liberty and Privacy International joined Apple to oppose the government's stance, arguing that maintaining secrecy after public leaks was farcical. Although the tribunal favored transparency regarding the notice's existence, specific private judgments remain sealed until future determinations are made.

Key points

  • The tribunal determined that acknowledging the surveillance order does not endanger natio…: The tribunal determined that acknowledging the surveillance order does not endanger national security due to prior public leaks.
  • Civil liberties groups Liberty and Privacy International supported Apple in challenging t…: Civil liberties groups Liberty and Privacy International supported Apple in challenging the state's strict secrecy policy.
  • A full legal trial concerning the actual substance of the encryption bypass demand will n…: A full legal trial concerning the actual substance of the encryption bypass demand will not occur until next year.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

LONDON, Nov 19 : The British government has issued an order to bypass encryption to access customer data held by Apple, a London tribunal confirmed on Thursday, rejecting an argument that revealing its existence could damage national security.

The government had said that it could not comment on the existence of the order, known as a technical capability notice, because it operated a policy of "neither confirm nor deny" on security matters.

However, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal said the amount of information already in the public domain meant that confirming it would do little, if any, damage.

There was no immediate comment from the British government or Apple. Campaign group Liberty, which challenged the government alongside Privacy International, called the ruling "a victory for transparency".

FIRST ORDER DROPPED AFTER US INTERVENTION

In January last year, Britain issued an initial notice for what is known as a back door to allow it access to encrypted cloud backups of data of US and British citizens.

That demand was dropped following months of negotiations with US President Donald Trump's administration, but in July…

Technology