Technology1 min read

UK Government Forced to Admit It Issued Apple a Secret Encryption Order

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The tribunal ruled against the government's standard policy to neither confirm nor deny the existence of a Technical Capability Notice sent to Apple. British authorities had previously tried to compel the company to provide backdoor access to encrypted iCloud data, initially seeking global reach before narrowing the request to domestic users. Apple responded to the mandates by pausing its Advanced Data Protection feature for new UK users and launching a fresh legal challenge in 2026. The decision directly follows legal pressure from civil rights groups Liberty and Privacy International, who argued extensive press coverage made official secrecy unjustifiable.

Key points

  • Civil rights groups successfully argued that widespread media coverage made the governmen…: Civil rights groups successfully argued that widespread media coverage made the government's continued official secrecy completely indefensible.
  • Diplomatic tension involving the Trump administration previously forced the UK to withdra…: Diplomatic tension involving the Trump administration previously forced the UK to withdraw a global backdoor order in favor of a domestic mandate.
  • The tribunal's decision lifts the barrier of state secrecy surrounding the order without…: The tribunal's decision lifts the barrier of state secrecy surrounding the order without revealing the full scope of surveillance demands.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal has rejected the UK government’s attempt to keep its order secret, marking a significant victory for transparency.

There's something pretty extraordinary about a government being able to demand changes to the security of devices used by millions of people, prevent a company that makes those devices from discussing those demands, and then refuse to even acknowledge that the demands exist at all.

That has been the sordid situation surrounding the UK governement's ongoing dispute with Apple over encrypted iCloud data. Up until today, the UK government's position has essentially been that it would neither confirm nor deny whether it issued Apple with a Technical Capability Notice (TCN). These are secret orders issued under Section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, which gives the UK government powers to require technology companies to make changes to their services to facilitate the exercise of investigatory powers. Today, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal has ruled that the UK government must acknowledge that it issued Apple with such a notice.

This is a big deal. Whilst it doesn't mean we suddenly…

Technology