Politics1 min read

UK government facing legal challenge over IHRA antisemitism definition in schools

By · Via Middle East Eye · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The British government's recommendation that schools implement the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance framework has prompted legal action led by the Good Law Project. Critics and civil society groups argue that because seven of the definition's 11 examples involve Israel, teachers could end up policing discussion on issues like Gaza and the Nakba. Furthermore, the foundational Bell review has drawn scrutiny for misrepresenting its survey findings, where widely cited claims of "three in five" affected students actually corresponded to 29 out of 70 respondents. The Department for Education maintains that the measure is necessary to safeguard Jewish pupils and staff from growing soci…

Key points

  • Lead author Kenneth Stern and legal experts caution that using the definition as a discip…: Lead author Kenneth Stern and legal experts caution that using the definition as a disciplinary mechanism chills legitimate political discourse.
  • The British Jewish group Na’amod warned that the policy risks forcing teachers to police…: The British Jewish group Na’amod warned that the policy risks forcing teachers to police student commentary on Gaza instead of tackling anti-Jewish prejudice.
  • The Department for Education defended its stance by arguing that antisemitism is expandin…: The Department for Education defended its stance by arguing that antisemitism is expanding across society and must be eradicated from schools.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

The British government is being challenged legally over its recommendation for schools to adopt the contested IHRA definition of antisemitism.

The Good Law Project launched a legal challenge against the government on Monday. The group’s executive director Jo Maugham told Middle East Eye he was worried that “rules which conflate criticism of Israel with antisemitism… could be among the drivers of antisemitism”.

“Antisemitism and the rise of antisemitism in Britain and around the world are very real things, and I want to say to British Jews who are at the sharp end, I hear your pain,” Maugham said.

“But I also worry - and it's a point I've made many times - that rules which conflate criticism of Israel with antisemitism, and that unjustifiably constrain the freedom properly and vigorously to criticise Israel, could be amongst the drivers of antisemitism.”

The UK Department of Education’s move to encourage schools to adopt the IHRA definition follows the recommendation made in British education official and academic David Bell's recently published report on antisemitism in the country's schools and colleges.

New MEE newsletter:…

Politics