Business1 min read

Turning on laptop didn't void refund, Court of Appeal rules in Argos case

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The two-year dispute concluded on 13 November 2026 after Argos refused to accept the return of a Lenovo IdeaPad laptop bought online via click-and-collect. Retail staff initially denied the refund because packaging had been opened and the pre-installed Windows 11 operating system was activated. Dr Ebenezer Adodo represented himself against the retailer, prompting the appellate court to rule that preloaded software is not equivalent to an exempt sealed software package. Argos was ordered to return the full purchase price with interest dating back to September 2024.

Key points

  • Customers retain full legal refund rights under distance selling laws even after booting…: Customers retain full legal refund rights under distance selling laws even after booting devices and setting up pre-installed software.
  • The Court of Appeal determined that purchasing a computer with preloaded software does no…: The Court of Appeal determined that purchasing a computer with preloaded software does not qualify as buying a separate sealed software package.
  • Retailers cannot restrict consumer rights on phones, computers, and electronics by citing…: Retailers cannot restrict consumer rights on phones, computers, and electronics by citing digital seal exemptions for bundled operating systems.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A University of Leicester academic who represented himself in court has won a legal battle against retail giant Argos in the Court of Appeal. The ruling protects online shoppers who switch on new laptops to check whether they work before deciding to return them. In a judgment issued on 13 November 2026 in the case of Adodo v Argos Limited, three senior judges unanimously ruled that activating pre-installed Windows 11 software does not remove a buyer's legal right to cancel an online purchase and receive a full refund. The decision ends a two-year legal dispute over a £379 Lenovo IdeaPad laptop. It also orders Argos to return the full purchase price, along with interest calculated from 14 days after the customer first tried to return the laptop in September 2024.

How the refund dispute started

According to the official judgment published by The National Archives, Dr Ebenezer Adodo ordered a Lenovo IdeaPad 1 laptop bundle from the Argos website on 31 August 2024. He also bought a mouse pad priced at £9.99. The total cost was £388.99, which he paid…

Business