Politics1 min read

This budget fails to live up to Andy Burnham’s grand rhetoric | Letters

By · Via The Guardian Business · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The government's new budget introduced small-scale cost-of-living reliefs, including a £100 energy payment, minor price cuts, and a temporary bank levy. However, critics point out that private utility surcharges quickly diminish these modest energy payments while frozen tax thresholds continue to penalize low-income earners. Commentators are instead demanding systemic changes, such as reforming capital gains tax to secure an estimated £19.7 billion annually. These redirected revenues could be utilized to construct 90,000 council homes and finance training for 128,000 NHS nurses.

Key points

  • Advocacy groups demand targeted taxes on major fortunes, corporate profits, and offshore…: Advocacy groups demand targeted taxes on major fortunes, corporate profits, and offshore holdings alongside strengthened HMRC collection capacity.
  • Modest citizen relief payments are being actively undermined by ongoing private utility s…: Modest citizen relief payments are being actively undermined by ongoing private utility surcharges and frozen income tax thresholds.
  • Proposed policy adjustments like ending standing energy charges have drawn scrutiny for p…: Proposed policy adjustments like ending standing energy charges have drawn scrutiny for potentially giving an unfair advantage to multi-home owners.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Aditya Chakrabortty was spot-on in his analysis of John Healey’s budget (Burnham promised big change – where was it? Instead we got the Martin Lewis budget, 28 October). It was a drop in the ocean of what is needed to bring about the scale of change this country needs and, importantly, was promised by Andy Burnham.

As the affordability crisis rages on, people may feel some relief at the small cost of living measures announced for households and businesses. But when we’ve been told we’ll get a wholesale reset and an end to neoliberalism, 4p off the price of gherkins and a temporary tiny bank tax isn’t going to cut it.

So, what’s the solution? The government must fairly tax the vast fortunes of the richest people and corporations, left mostly untouched. Recouping the massive wealth and profits siphoned off to shady tax havens each year, equalising how the tax system treats income from wealth and work, and building HMRC’s capacity to properly measure and collect tax from the very richest would raise tens of billions to help pay for…

Politics