Politics1 min read

The myth of Israel as the region's 'only democracy' should be dead. Not in western media

By · Via Middle East Eye · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Following the recent election, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud party leveled unsubstantiated claims accusing Arab parties of stealing votes, prompting an intelligence investigation despite police finding no supporting evidence. Although opposition factions technically hold a majority of seats alongside Palestinian-led parties, leader Gadi Eisenkot has set ideological conditions that effectively bar Arab politicians from governing coalitions. Meanwhile, surveys by the Israel Democracy Institute reveal that up to 75 percent of Jewish Israelis oppose Arab parties joining or supporting a government. Potential power-sharing discussions between Netanyahu and Eisenkot further ensure that…

Key points

  • Record electoral participation by Palestinian-led parties has not translated into politic…: Record electoral participation by Palestinian-led parties has not translated into political influence due to broad structural and coalition-level exclusion.
  • Mainstream political leaders from both the governing bloc and the opposition remain align…: Mainstream political leaders from both the governing bloc and the opposition remain aligned in barring Arab factions from governance.
  • Large swaths of the population living under Israeli territorial control remain completely…: Large swaths of the population living under Israeli territorial control remain completely disenfranchised from the national electoral process.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

For much of the western media, Israel’s election was a festival of democracy. La Croix billed it as a vote for peace and “the honour of democracy”. The BBC framed it as a pivotal election “defined by security and democracy”.

The New York Times cast it as hard-right nationalism against Israel’s “founding ideals”. Le Monde gave it extensive coverage with seemingly little regard for the expectations of Palestinians, the axis of the whole campaign.

But the numbers are now in, and they tell a story the democracy-worshippers have chosen not to read.

The morning after the vote, Yair Netanyahu, the son of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, said the results proved that most Muslim Arabs in Israel support terrorism against the state, calling it “an existential problem no less than the Iranian nuclear threat”. Their offence? They voted.

He was not freelancing. Likud, in a statement his father shared, claimed the election had been stolen by Arab parties, offering no specific evidence; police said there was none.

New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch

Sign up to get the latest insights and…

Politics