Technology1 min read

The HomeView and Echo Show 16 could be the family computers I’ve been asking for

By · Via The Verge · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The new premium smart displays move away from entry-level hardware to deliver robust communal computing without requiring PINs or clearing screensavers. Both devices are built to handle central household management like smart home controls and meal planning, replacing older budget alternatives like the $85 Echo Show 5 and $99 Nest Hub. However, the hardware represents starkly different ecosystem philosophies regarding standalone operation. While Amazon built an entirely phone-free communal screen, Apple tied its new display directly to an iPhone pairing.

Key points

  • Hardware manufacturers are shifting to higher prices to support computer-grade components…: Hardware manufacturers are shifting to higher prices to support computer-grade components capable of running always-on household utilities.
  • Amazon built its screen to operate as a completely standalone household fixture that requ…: Amazon built its screen to operate as a completely standalone household fixture that requires no smartphone even during setup.
  • Apple positioned its display as an iPhone accessory, restricting its communal functionali…: Apple positioned its display as an iPhone accessory, restricting its communal functionality unless it stays paired with a personal phone.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Three years ago, I wrote an obituary for the smart display. The category — smart speakers with touchscreens attached — was stuck with a few underpowered gadgets from Google and Amazon that tried to do too much and did too little well. Back then, I also laid out what they needed to do to improve. This month, Apple and Amazon launched new smart displays that check nearly every box on that list.

The HomeView and Echo Show 16 could be the family computers I’ve been asking for

Apple’s and Amazon’s new home devices might finally make the smart display genuinely useful. But they’re taking opposite approaches to get there.

The HomeView and Echo Show 16 could be the family computers I’ve been asking for

Apple’s and Amazon’s new home devices might finally make the smart display genuinely useful. But they’re taking opposite approaches to get there.

Based on my brief hands-on time with Apple’s first smart display, the $299 HomeView, and Amazon’s $499.99 Echo Show 16, a ground-up rebuild of its smart display line, these could finally turn the smart…

Technology