Other1 min read

Texas court scraps $796,906 award in grandmother's diamond and cash dispute

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The conflict began after the August 2019 death of Joyce Kezhaya, whose grandson Nathanial Reggish emptied her safe-deposit box and claimed it contained just $16,000, a Bible, and personal items. Stephens sued, supported by a daughter of the deceased who testified the box actually held an eight-carat diamond ring, gold coins, and $400,000 in cash. A trial court subsequently entered a $796,905.89 judgment against Reggish for fraud, conspiracy, and wrongful taking of property. However, the appeals court vacated the award because Stephens failed to assert her ownership rights before the estate officially closed in March 2021.

Key points

  • Failure to pursue property claims before an estate officially closes can legally extingui…: Failure to pursue property claims before an estate officially closes can legally extinguish an otherwise successful jury verdict.
  • The Texas appeals court overturned the $796,905.89 award on strict procedural grounds rat…: The Texas appeals court overturned the $796,905.89 award on strict procedural grounds rather than determining the box's actual contents.
  • Nathanial Reggish was relieved of financial liability for claims of fraud, conspiracy, an…: Nathanial Reggish was relieved of financial liability for claims of fraud, conspiracy, and wrongful taking due to the missed probate timeline.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A Texas woman's decision to share access to her bank safe-deposit box with her niece led to a family dispute involving claims of $400,000 in cash, an eight-carat diamond ring and gold coins.

According to the details of the case available on

Justia, the disagreement began after Joyce Kezhaya died in August 2019, when her grandson emptied the box and reported finding only $16,000. Her niece later took him to court and won nearly $797,000 in damages. However, on Tuesday, a Texas appeals court overturned the award, ruling that she had failed to make her claim through the required process before her aunt's estate was settled.

At the centre of the case was a question that remained unresolved even after years of legal proceedings: what was actually inside the bank box? Kezhaya's grandson, Nathanial Reggish, maintained that it contained $16,000, a family Bible and a few other belongings. But one of Kezhaya's daughters told the court that she had seen a much larger amount of cash, along with valuable jewellery and gold coins.

The woman who brought the case, Kezhaya…

Other