Other1 min read

Texas appeals court blocks DNA test in cousin's fight over handwritten will

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The dispute arose after John Demel passed away without a spouse or children, leaving his real estate, money, personal property, and animals to two unrelated individuals through a handwritten document. When beneficiary Chris Quijada moved to probate the document, first cousin once removed Peter Demel intervened to challenge its legal standing. Justice Katy Boatman ruled that the probate court erred in ordering Peter to provide biological samples at the National Screening Center under the Texas Family Code prior to resolving the will's legitimacy.

Key points

  • Probate courts lack the authority to order genetic testing for relatives before resolving…: Probate courts lack the authority to order genetic testing for relatives before resolving the validity of a challenged will.
  • Peter Demel is actively contesting the legal standing of the handwritten will that exclud…: Peter Demel is actively contesting the legal standing of the handwritten will that excludes him from John Demel's estate.
  • The appellate decision officially directs Harris County Probate Court No. 5 to cancel its…: The appellate decision officially directs Harris County Probate Court No. 5 to cancel its order requiring Peter Demel's DNA submission.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A Texas man who died without a spouse or children left his property, money, personal belongings and animals to two people named in a handwritten will. But when his first cousin once removed challenged the document, a probate judge ordered DNA testing to confirm their family connection. A Texas appeals court has now stopped the test, ruling that the lower court did not have the legal power to order it while the will dispute remains unresolved. The Texas Fourteenth Court of Appeals issued its decision on 17 November 2026 in a case involving Peter K. Demel and the estate of John Demel. The judges found that the probate court had wrongly ordered Peter to provide DNA samples before deciding whether John's handwritten will was valid.

The ruling means Peter cannot be forced to undergo genetic testing under the existing order. The appeals court also instructed the probate court to cancel its direction requiring him to take the test. According to the judgment published by Justia, the case is recorded as In re Peter K. Demel, case number 14-26-00320-CV, from Probate…

Other