Politics1 min read

Teacher fired over Covid tests wins ruling after school board skips hearing

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Neal Follman was terminated from his position at Constitution High School after refusing mandatory weekly in-person screening protocols in May 2021. Although the district held a virtual hearing in February 2022, only an appointed hearing officer presided over the session. The school board later cast a unanimous 9-0 vote to fire him without having attended the proceedings. Justice David Wecht affirmed that the Pennsylvania Public School Code strictly prevents boards from completely delegating tenure dismissal hearings.

Key points

  • School districts in Pennsylvania cannot lawfully delegate the entirety of a tenured teach…: School districts in Pennsylvania cannot lawfully delegate the entirety of a tenured teacher's dismissal hearing to an appointed officer.
  • Elected school board members must personally conduct termination hearings rather than sim…: Elected school board members must personally conduct termination hearings rather than simply reviewing transcripts before voting on dismissals.
  • The Philadelphia school district must reinstate the dismissed educator with back pay unle…: The Philadelphia school district must reinstate the dismissed educator with back pay unless it executes a proper, lawful hearing process.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A Philadelphia teacher who lost his job after refusing to undergo weekly Covid-19 tests has won a legal battle that began during the pandemic. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled in his favour, finding that the school district violated state law by holding his termination hearing without a single elected school board member present.

The ruling, delivered on November 17, concerns Neal Follman, a teacher in the School District of Philadelphia. The court upheld an earlier decision ordering the district to reinstate him with back pay unless it properly terminates his employment in accordance with the law.

The case turned on a question of procedure: can a school board delegate a tenured teacher's dismissal hearing entirely to an appointed hearing officer, then decide the teacher's fate by reviewing the record afterwards? The state's highest court said no.

Why the teacher refused Covid testing

According to the Pennsylvania Department of Education's official record, Follman was employed by the Philadelphia School District from January 2010 and worked at Constitution High School during the 2020-21 school year.

On February 22, 2021, the district's…

Politics