Other1 min read

Sydney woman loses court fight over 3cm carport encroachment after its removal

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The conflict in Lane Cove North originated over 1984-era structures, including garage and carport gutters along with a post that crossed the boundary line by 3 to 13 centimetres. While the neighbours agreed to clear the intrusions, the plaintiff launched legal action in July 2025 following logistical holdups and an accidental modification of the wrong post by a contractor. A joint inspection in May 2026 verified that all structures were removed, leading the court to dismiss the plaintiff's subsequent demand for over $56,000 in damages and costs.

Key points

  • Justice Pike determined the neighbours demonstrated a consistent intent to rectify the en…: Justice Pike determined the neighbours demonstrated a consistent intent to rectify the encroachments, which justified dismissing the summons.
  • Both parties must pay their own legal costs because the court found no unreasonable condu…: Both parties must pay their own legal costs because the court found no unreasonable conduct or formal capitulation by the respondents.
  • The formal confirmation of the removal during a May 2026 joint inspection effectively res…: The formal confirmation of the removal during a May 2026 joint inspection effectively resolved the substantive property encroachment claims.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A Sydney woman took her neighbours to the Supreme Court of New South Wales over structures that extended onto her property, including a carport post that crossed the boundary by just 3 cm. The dispute involved adjoining homes in Lane Cove North and also covered a carport gutter and a garage eave and gutter, each found to encroach by about 13 cm.

According to a judgment published by the Supreme Court of New South Wales, the neighbours accepted a boundary determination and agreed to remove the structures before the proceedings began. The work took longer than the woman wanted and involved several surveys and further repairs. The court later dismissed her summons and ordered each side to pay its own legal costs.

Sydney woman discovered three carport and garage encroachments on her land

The structures had been in place since 1984. The dispute began after the woman engaged C&A Surveyors in June 2022 to survey the shared boundary before building a new dividing fence between the two neighbouring homes.

The survey identified the encroachments and recommended a redefinition survey. The…

Other