Business1 min read

Simply telling the AA about my minor no-fault, no-claim prang doubled my insurance quote

By · Via The Guardian Money · Published by Everything Blog

In short

A Lancashire motorist saw their insurance renewal quote surge to £796.86 after informing the AA of a minor, no-fault collision that involved no insurance claims. A call handler subsequently lowered the figure to £452.31 while asserting that premium increases were standard industry practice across all providers. Following an inquiry, the AA conceded that internal systems and staff had made an error and agreed to honour the initial £364 quote.

Key points

  • Policyholders risk invalidating their insurance coverage if they fail to report minor, no…: Policyholders risk invalidating their insurance coverage if they fail to report minor, no-fault accidents to their provider.
  • Underwriting algorithms often assess drivers involved in any accident as statistically mo…: Underwriting algorithms often assess drivers involved in any accident as statistically more likely to experience future collisions.
  • The AA fully reinstated the original £364 renewal quote after acknowledging system and st…: The AA fully reinstated the original £364 renewal quote after acknowledging system and staff errors.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

My car was involved in a minor no-fault accident. The other driver admitted responsibility and said they would pay for repairs without involving insurers. I informed my insurer, the AA, without making a claim. It had recently sent a renewal quote for £364, but after reporting the accident I was sent a revised figure of £796.86.

I was told by a call handler that any insurance company would do the same. However, they eventually lowered the quote to £452.31. This seems extortionate for a no-fault, no-claim prang.

DR, Lancashire

You’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t. Failure to report an accident, even if it’s minor, not your fault and you don’t plan to claim, could invalidate your policy.

The algorithms that insurers use to assess risk tend to assume that one prang makes you statistically more likely to have another, regardless of blame. Plus, you, or the at-fault driver, might later decide to claim for said incident.

However, when I asked the AA how it justified doubling your premium, it discovered that its system and the call…

Business