Politics1 min read

Shenzhen was not Yalta, but Europe was definitively sidelined

By · Via Middle East Eye · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The briefing reports that the trilateral discussions focused on United Nations reforms, pledges to boost refined petroleum supplies, and commitments to lower nuclear risks. The participants affirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and established a trilateral risk-reduction dialogue, while asserting state consent against International Criminal Court jurisdiction. However, the resulting declaration completely bypassed major international conflicts, including the war in Ukraine, tensions surrounding Taiwan, and the crisis in Gaza. Furthermore, the three leaders did not commit to establishing a schedule for regular follow-up meetings.

Key points

  • The three leaders established a trilateral dialogue on reducing nuclear risks while reaff…: The three leaders established a trilateral dialogue on reducing nuclear risks while reaffirming that a nuclear war cannot be won.
  • The joint statement completely omitted pressing global flashpoints such as Gaza, Taiwan,…: The joint statement completely omitted pressing global flashpoints such as Gaza, Taiwan, North Korea, and the Russia-Ukraine war.
  • The participating nations issued a direct warning to the International Criminal Court reg…: The participating nations issued a direct warning to the International Criminal Court regarding official immunities and state consent.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

The first-ever US-Russia-China summit produced a thin declaration, and no carve-up of the world. But the format itself - three powers, one table, no Europeans - might matter more than anything they signed.

In February 1945, US President Franklin Roosevelt, UK Prime Minister Winston Churchill and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin met in Yalta to settle the shape of the postwar world.

Eight decades later, Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin sat down on the sidelines of the Apec summit in Shenzhen for the first trilateral meeting ever held among the leaders of the US, China and Russia.

The comparison was irresistible. Yet after roughly 90 minutes of talks, what emerged was far more modest: a four-point joint “Declaration toward Peace”. The statement’s text suggests that what was supposed to be a historic event was mostly just a photo op.

This brings to mind another photograph, one that adorned the front page of The New York Times a quarter of a century ago, during a United Nations summit in New York in September 2000 that was meant to mark the…

Politics