Politics1 min read

Shabana Mahmood has barely softened her plans – Britain’s immigration regime is now a theatre of cruelty | Owen Jones

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Under the new immigration rules, migrant workers will see their standard qualifying period for secure residence doubled to 10 years, which applies retrospectively to around half a million lawful residents. In contrast, individuals earning more than £125,000 can qualify for settlement in just three years. Asylum seekers face even steeper penalties, with small-boat arrivals potentially enduring waits of up to 30 years. Meanwhile, social care workers who arrived before May 2025 retain a five-year route despite the sector struggling with nearly 100,000 vacancies.

Key points

  • The retroactive application of the 10-year baseline directly impacts an estimated half a…: The retroactive application of the 10-year baseline directly impacts an estimated half a million people currently residing in the UK.
  • The UK provides no overseas asylum visa routes, requiring individuals to be physically pr…: The UK provides no overseas asylum visa routes, requiring individuals to be physically present to claim protection.
  • Reopened resettlement programmes leave people fleeing nations like Iran, Eritrea, and Som…: Reopened resettlement programmes leave people fleeing nations like Iran, Eritrea, and Somalia without legal pathways to claim British asylum from abroad.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Five years ago, Shabana Mahmood called for a “general amnesty” for undocumented migrants. “That’s not official Labour party policy yet,” she mourned, “but myself and a group of other Labour MPs are continuing to make the argument.”

Now home secretary, she is introducing one of Europe’s most punitive immigration and asylum systems. The standard qualifying period for migrant workers to gain secure residence will double to 10 years, which will be twice the length set out in almost all EU countries. The standard wait for refugees who claim asylum in Britain outside designated resettlement routes will be 20 years, four times the usual five-year qualifying period in Germany, Spain and Italy.

But even this is misleading. As the Home Office notes: “There are no visa routes to enable people to claim asylum in the UK from overseas.” As it further adds: “A person must be present in the UK to claim asylum here.” So accessing this punitive process by regular means is in essence impossible.

Mahmood has reopened an exceptionally limited resettlement scheme, with Afghan women and girls and Palestinians…

Politics