Other1 min read

Scottish couple say 17 trees aren't a hedge; ordered to trim after complaints

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The dispute centered on whether 17 individual trees and shrubs planted along a Musselburgh boundary wall fell under the scope of the High Hedges (Scotland) Act 2013. The legislation legally defines a high hedge as two or more trees or shrubs exceeding two metres in height that create a barrier to natural light. While upholding the council's reduction order, the reporter exempted an ash tree and a willow tree from the required trimming. Additionally, the homeowners were granted an extended deadline to ensure the required work takes place outside the bird-nesting season.

Key points

  • Homeowners must cut back and maintain their disputed boundary vegetation at a maximum hei…: Homeowners must cut back and maintain their disputed boundary vegetation at a maximum height of approximately eight feet.
  • Neighbors successfully demonstrated that the overgrown row significantly obstructed natur…: Neighbors successfully demonstrated that the overgrown row significantly obstructed natural daylight and deposited unwanted debris onto their grounds.
  • Compliance deadlines were extended specifically to prevent the required cutting operation…: Compliance deadlines were extended specifically to prevent the required cutting operations from interfering with the local bird-nesting season.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A property dispute in East Lothian, Scotland, has ended with a couple being ordered to reduce the height of a row of trees and shrubs after authorities ruled that the planting qualified as a high hedge under Scottish law. Professor Angus Macdonald and Dr Patricia Macdonald had challenged the order, arguing that their garden boundary consisted of 17 individual trees and shrubs rather than a hedge. However, a Scottish Government reporter upheld the council’s decision following an inspection of the properties. The case was reported by STV News and Midlothian View, with further details of Scotland’s high hedge legislation available through the Scottish Government.

How the dispute began

The disagreement arose at the couple’s property in Ashgrove, Musselburgh, which falls within the Musselburgh Conservation Area. Their neighbours approached East Lothian Council, complaining that the boundary vegetation was growing over their property, dropping leaves, berries and other debris, and significantly restricting their access to natural light.

Following the complaint, East Lothian Council issued a High Hedge Notice requiring the couple to reduce the height of the planting.

The Macdonalds challenged the…

Other