Climate1 min read

Right to breathe: Can you take the government to court over polluted air?

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Supreme Court has expanded the Article 21 right to life to include clean air, reinforced by precedents such as the 1991 Subhash Kumar v. State of Bihar ruling. Aggrieved residents can approach high courts, the Supreme Court, or the National Green Tribunal to penalize polluters and force regulatory compliance. However, legal and environmental specialists caution that persistent weak enforcement and reactive frameworks undermine these safeguards. Furthermore, mitigation is crippled by monitoring gaps, with active tracking stations covering only 47 percent of Delhi's area.

Key points

  • Authorities are legally prohibited from citing financial constraints to evade their envir…: Authorities are legally prohibited from citing financial constraints to evade their environmental pollution control duties.
  • Citizens can seek compensation and industrial closures by filing public interest litigati…: Citizens can seek compensation and industrial closures by filing public interest litigations under Articles 32 or 226.
  • Emergency measures like the Graded Response Action Plan remain ineffective reactive tools…: Emergency measures like the Graded Response Action Plan remain ineffective reactive tools that fail to resolve year-round pollution sources.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

NEW DELHI: Air pollution has become a recurring concern for cities across India, with its effects extending beyond seasonal smog and deteriorating air quality. While governments rely on pollution-control measures and emergency restrictions to tackle the crisis, the larger challenge is ensuring that people are protected from the harmful effects of polluted air.

Currently, Delhi's AQI stands at 491, while Mumbai recorded 132, placing both cities in the poor or worse air quality range. The figures highlight how pollution is affecting cities across the country. With emergency restrictions offering only temporary relief, the question of whether clean air can be treated as a fundamental right becomes very important.

Is clean air a legal right in India?Adesh Nandal, Legal Associate at Jotwani Associates, said the Constitution does not specifically mention a fundamental right to clean air. However, courts have interpreted the right to life under Article 21 to include the right to live in a pollution-free environment.

In Subhash Kumar v. State of Bihar (1991), the Supreme Court held that the right to life includes the right to enjoy pollution-free water…

Climate