Artificial Intelligence1 min read

Ram through datacentres no one wants and hope the AI bubble never bursts: that’s the UK’s growth plan | George Monbiot

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The UK government is pushing forward with planning dispensations for datacentres under the assumption that the infrastructure will anchor national economic growth. However, critics fear the rapid construction is merely inflating tech stock valuations rather than fulfilling authentic market needs. On a local level, the projects threaten host communities with intense water usage, high energy demands, light pollution, and increased emissions. This approach is being reinforced by Keir Starmer's proposed regulating for growth bill, which aims to weaken standard corporate restrictions through regulatory sandboxes.

Key points

  • Fast-tracking datacentre approvals without defined operational uses risks creating extens…: Fast-tracking datacentre approvals without defined operational uses risks creating extensive landscape blight and significant public decommissioning expenses.
  • Unchecked technological infrastructure growth threatens surrounding communities with seve…: Unchecked technological infrastructure growth threatens surrounding communities with severe resource depletion, emissions, and light pollution.
  • Relying on aggressive deregulation mirrors past speculative bubbles in the fossil fuel an…: Relying on aggressive deregulation mirrors past speculative bubbles in the fossil fuel and financial sectors that ended in crashes.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

It should have the status of an economic law: the sectors a government does most to promote in the name of growth are the sectors most likely to tank the economy. In the UK and the US, deregulation was meant to turn the financial sector into a never-ending growth machine. We have not yet fully recovered from the crash it helped cause in 2008. Fossil fuels are the most heavily subsidised sector on Earth. All that public money makes us highly vulnerable to oil price shocks, the whims of autocrats and societal collapse caused by climate breakdown. As for the great growth priority of our time – AI and datacentres – well, don’t take it from me. As Anthropic’s IPO prospectus warns, advanced AI systems could pose “catastrophic or existential risks to humanity”.

One thing we learned from the US midterm elections is that the drive to build datacentres is less a function of real commercial demand than of the need to sustain the share price of the big tech companies. After citizens across the US voted for moratoria on…

Artificial Intelligence