Finance1 min read

Property seller's story saves him from cash penalty

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Chennai overturned the Rs 6.75 lakh penalty levied against property seller Mr Vijayasarathy. He had accepted the cash advance from a senior citizen from Vellore to finalize the Rs 32 lakh deal on the spot and spare the buyer from traveling back with the money. Represented by FCA S. Vidhya, the seller proved that the transaction was entirely bona fide by recording the cash in the registered deed and depositing it directly into his bank. The tribunal affirmed that these circumstances, paired with full capital gains tax compliance, constituted a valid reasonable cause.

Key points

  • Taxpayers can avoid penalties under Section 273B if they establish a genuine reasonable c…: Taxpayers can avoid penalties under Section 273B if they establish a genuine reasonable cause for accepting cash.
  • Transparent reporting alone does not prove reasonable cause, but honest disclosure combin…: Transparent reporting alone does not prove reasonable cause, but honest disclosure combined with extenuating transaction circumstances protects sellers.
  • Depositing cash receipts into a bank account and paying due capital gains tax helps demon…: Depositing cash receipts into a bank account and paying due capital gains tax helps demonstrate the bona fide nature of a deal.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

Mr Vijayasarathy from K.K.Nagar got into problems with the Income Tax Department while selling his Chennai property for Rs 32 lakh to a senior citizen property buyer. The reason for this trouble is Vijayasarathy took Rs 6.75 lakh cash from this senior citizen property buyer while the remaining amount was taken in his bank account. This whole arrangement was disclosed in the sale deed also.

When asked why he accepted the cash, Vijayasarathy said that he urgently needed to sell his residential property and had asked a broker to find a buyer. The broker found a senior citizen buyer from Vellore and invited him to Chennai to view the property.

However, the senior citizen buyer had carried Rs 6.75 lakh cash with him and when he reached Chennai and saw Vijayasarathy’s property, he liked it and on the spot made an offer to him. To secure the deal, the buyer offered Rs 6.75 lakh in cash to Vijayasarathy as an advance. He told Vijayasarathy that he did not want to carry this cash back with him to Vellore and also…

Finance