Health1 min read

Patient safety chief concerned about NHS Grampian

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The controversy emerged after consultant Dr. Mohammed Habib leaked an unpublished 2022 internal review examining surgeries performed at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. That document revealed that 19 patient deaths between 2015 and 2021 were deemed avoidable consequences of surgical interventions. Health Secretary Angela Constance has demanded immediate, sustained improvements while defending current safety standards across regional hospitals. Meanwhile, health board leadership maintains that extensive investigations have occurred and any further evidence will be formally assessed.

Key points

  • Scotland's Patient Safety Commissioner has formally requested independent assurance to ve…: Scotland's Patient Safety Commissioner has formally requested independent assurance to verify that necessary safety reforms are taking place.
  • The Scottish Government has demanded immediate and sustained improvements despite asserti…: The Scottish Government has demanded immediate and sustained improvements despite asserting that current patients remain safe.
  • NHS Grampian leadership confirmed ongoing clinical reviews and pledged to examine any eme…: NHS Grampian leadership confirmed ongoing clinical reviews and pledged to examine any emerging evidence through formal governance channels.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

- Published

Scotland's Patient Safety Commissioner has said she is not confident all the facts about concerns raised at NHS Grampian have yet come to light.

Karen Titchener told BBC Scotland she is seeking "independent assurance" that change is being implemented at NHS Grampian and it is "totally unacceptable" that the health secretary was not aware of the issues.

It comes after Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI) leaked an unpublished review from 2022 which found 19 avoidable deaths among 45 patients in liver and pancreatic surgery.

NHS Grampian said it is aware of the issues raised and an investigation has already taken place.

Titchener told the BBC's Radio Scotland Breakfast: "We can't just ask the team that's been going in to fix the problem to give that assurance.

"We have to make sure that change is improving things and is happening rather than just the assumption."

Titchener added it is important people at the hospital "feel like they can speak up" but Habib's claims suggests people are "still not feeling heard".

Asked if she was…

Health