Health1 min read

Opinion: New organ donation rules are unfair to families

By · Via STAT Health · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network designed the shift to quickly secure viable organs, but specialists warn it compromises the clear boundary between end-of-life care and organ retrieval. These ethical concerns are compounded by recent Department of Health and Human Services data showing dozens of improper donation authorizations. Specifically, 73 cases in 2025 involved authorized donors who still displayed neurological signs incompatible with donation.

Key points

  • Allowing procurement teams to intervene before life support is discontinued threatens to…: Allowing procurement teams to intervene before life support is discontinued threatens to undermine public confidence in medical teams.
  • Recent findings reveal that some individuals in small or rural medical facilities were po…: Recent findings reveal that some individuals in small or rural medical facilities were potentially not dead when procurement efforts started.
  • While brain death assessments remain strictly standardized across the nation, donations r…: While brain death assessments remain strictly standardized across the nation, donations relying on circulatory death depend on prognostic evaluations that are difficult to standardize.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

I watched Hailey’s chest without pause, searching for the slightest movement, a tiny intake of breath, any sign of life.

Hailey (not her real name) was 22 years old, a college student who had suffered a catastrophic brain injury in a traffic accident. She lay before me in our neuroscience intensive care unit, her heart beating steadily, her skin warm, a ventilator breathing for her. I was performing an apnea test, the final step in determining whether she had died by neurological criteria. It’s part of my job as a neurointensivist at Oregon Health & Science University. The longest 10 minutes of my life are those I spend watching for any small chest movement as we remove a patient from a breathing machine. I can’t let my eyes wander. I can’t blink. Hailey never took a breath; she was brain dead.

Her parents sat vigil for two days, waiting for her sister to arrive from overseas so she could say goodbye. When they finally accepted that their daughter had died, the organ donation team took over.

Six months later, our…

Health