Other1 min read

Ohio couple gave land for 10 cents in 1843; court upholds public square rule

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The dispute originated when developers sought to clear historical title encumbrances on a fraction of the 2.63-acre parcel to enable a commercial land sale. A 2018 transaction involving a 0.2596-acre strip had reaffirmed the original 1857 recorded restrictions, but the buyers subsequently filed a lawsuit in April 2024 to invalidate them. The Eleventh District Court of Appeals affirmed that the conditions established in 1843 remain active, safeguarding the grounds that currently feature an 1887 bandstand and a gazebo.

Key points

  • The Ohio Eleventh District Court of Appeals ruled that the 1843 land-use restrictions rem…: The Ohio Eleventh District Court of Appeals ruled that the 1843 land-use restrictions remain legally enforceable today.
  • Commercial developers failed to invalidate historical covenants intended to preserve publ…: Commercial developers failed to invalidate historical covenants intended to preserve public parkland in Geauga County.
  • Neighboring property owner A.L.L., Inc. was denied intervention because the township adeq…: Neighboring property owner A.L.L., Inc. was denied intervention because the township adequately represented local interests.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

An Ohio court has upheld a land-use rule from 1843, keeping a piece of town land safe as a public square more than 180 years after a couple sold it to a local township for just 10 cents. On 16 November 2026, the Ohio Court of Appeals for the Eleventh District ruled that the rule on the land is still valid and can be enforced, even after developers tried to fight it in court. The case focuses on 2.63 acres given by Simon and Nancy Perkins to Parkman Township, Ohio, on the condition that local people could use it as a public square or open green space.

The ruling also turned down an appeal from A.L.L., Inc., a nearby property owner that wanted to join the legal battle to protect the land. The appeals judges agreed that Parkman Township was already speaking up for the same things A.L.L. wanted to protect. According to the court ruling published by Justia, the case involved BTE Properties, L.L.C., ABC Development, L.L.C., A.L.L., Inc. and Parkman Township. Judge John J. Eklund wrote the decision,…

Other