Other1 min read

'Officials can't use common sense' - was Rogers handball correct?

By · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Referee Michael Oliver awarded the spot-kick after Jayden Bogle's strike hit Rogers, enabling Leeds to take the lead. Video assistant referee Michael Salisbury upheld the call because Rogers lifted his arm from his midriff into the ball's path, meeting the threshold for a deliberate act within the punishable upper-arm area. Pundit Alan Shearer strongly disputed the ruling, arguing that Rogers was simply shielding his face rather than attempting to gain an unfair advantage.

Key points

  • Officials determined Rogers committed a deliberate act because he raised his arm into the…: Officials determined Rogers committed a deliberate act because he raised his arm into the ball's path after a long-range strike.
  • The contact was classified as a punishable handball because the ball struck Rogers high o…: The contact was classified as a punishable handball because the ball struck Rogers high on his arm in the red zone.
  • The controversial call underscores an ongoing divide between strict rule enforcement and…: The controversial call underscores an ongoing divide between strict rule enforcement and the desire for common sense officiating.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

- Published

It is rare when a key handball decision is given for the widespread response to be "that is correct".

Often the discussion centres on the desire for a seemingly more lenient interpretation taking into account perceived intent.

And that is again a talking point after the crucial penalty given against Chelsea in Saturday's 4-1 home defeat by Leeds which ended up putting the visitors ahead for the first time.

Interestingly, despite the perception, handball penalties are much rarer in the Premier League compared with the other top five leagues in Europe.

Last season, there were 22 penalties for handball in the English top flight's 380 games - easily the lowest tally.

Spain's La Liga (36) and Italy's Serie A (38) produced the most.

This season in the Premier League there have been three in 106 matches - less than in 2025-26.

So why was the penalty given against Chelsea's Morgan Rogers?

Why the penalty was given

The feeling among Premier League clubs is that handball is in a good place now, where the arm must either be fully…

Other