Other1 min read

NY woman can pursue rent stabilisation claim after 20 years on commercial lease

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously affirmed a lower court ruling that denied summary judgment to the property owner, 38 East 64th Street, LLC. The owner sought to evict E. Terese Carpenter, along with recovering legal fees and occupancy payments, based on a commercial lease signed around 2006 by her company, Nile, Inc. However, Carpenter has inhabited the Manhattan unit for more than 20 years, while the building's certificate of occupancy permits only residential use. The court found that unresolved questions regarding the landlord's awareness of her actual living situation preclude an immediate eviction.

Key points

  • Disputed facts regarding the landlord's knowledge of residential use prevent the summary…: Disputed facts regarding the landlord's knowledge of residential use prevent the summary eviction of the tenant.
  • Executing a commercial lease cannot readily circumvent New York's Rent Stabilisation Law…: Executing a commercial lease cannot readily circumvent New York's Rent Stabilisation Law when a building is certified solely for residential occupancy.
  • Counterclaims regarding unlawful apartment deregulation must be fully resolved before the…: Counterclaims regarding unlawful apartment deregulation must be fully resolved before the property owner can collect occupancy payments or recover possession.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A New York landlord's attempt to recover possession of an apartment has suffered a setback after an appeals court allowed a long-running dispute over rent-stabilisation protections to proceed. The case centres on E. Terese Carpenter, who says she has lived in a Manhattan apartment for more than 20 years, even though the landlord required a company she owned to sign a commercial lease describing the space as being used exclusively for business. In a November 19, 2026

decision, available on Justia, the New York Supreme Court's Appellate Division, First Department, upheld a lower court's refusal to grant the landlord summary judgment, finding that there were unresolved questions about the apartment's actual residential use and the landlord's knowledge of it. The ruling in 38 E. 64th St., LLC v. Nile, Inc. allows Carpenter's rent-stabilisation claims to continue.

Landlord sought to recover the Manhattan apartment

The dispute involves an apartment in a building at 38 East 64th Street in Manhattan. The landlord, 38 East 64th Street, LLC, rented the unit to Nile, Inc., a company owned by Carpenter, beginning in or around…

Other