Climate1 min read

NH homeowners' well-pollution claim against plastics plant can proceed as group

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The First Circuit decision partially upholds a lawsuit filed against Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics over perfluorooctanoic acid emissions that spread through facility exhaust stacks. State regulators originally uncovered the issue in 2016 when tap testing inside the plant triggered wider tests of local wells and utilities. Although the trespass claim will move forward collectively, judges determined that negligence and failure-to-warn allegations require individualized inquiries that are unsuitable for a group action. Private well sampling revealed contamination reaching 1,600 parts per trillion, vastly exceeding New Hampshire's regulatory limit of 70 parts per trillion.

Key points

  • Homeowners can collectively pursue a trespass claim, but they cannot proceed as a class f…: Homeowners can collectively pursue a trespass claim, but they cannot proceed as a class for negligence or failure to warn.
  • Plaintiffs are demanding financial compensation for plummeting property values, ongoing c…: Plaintiffs are demanding financial compensation for plummeting property values, ongoing cleanup efforts, and alternative water supplies.
  • The litigation stems from decades of manufacturing fiberglass and films using hazardous f…: The litigation stems from decades of manufacturing fiberglass and films using hazardous fluorinated chemicals at the Merrimack plant.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A federal appeals court has allowed a group of New Hampshire homeowners to continue their class-action trespass claim against Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corporation over chemical pollution in their drinking water. However, the court overturned class-action approval for two related claims involving negligence and failure to warn. In a ruling issued on 17 November 2026 in Brown v. Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corp. (No. 24-1869), the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit upheld a lower court's decision allowing homeowners to pursue the company's responsibility for trespass as a group. But the appeals court rejected group treatment for the negligence and failure-to-warn claims. It found that deciding those claims would require too many separate checks of individual properties.

The case involves a manufacturing plant on the left bank of the Merrimack River in Merrimack, New Hampshire. The plant is surrounded by the communities of Bedford, Manchester, Londonderry and Litchfield. Since the 1980s, Saint-Gobain and its previous owner, ChemFab Corporation, have made chemical-resistant and weather-resistant fibreglass and films at the site using perfluorooctanoic acid, known as PFOA.

The homeowners, led by named…

Climate