Politics1 min read

‘New page in history?’ Xi, Trump and Putin summit was more of a footnote

By · Via The Guardian · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The joint statement released by the leaders broadly referenced United Nations reform, energy supply growth, nuclear disarmament, and curbing the International Criminal Court, yet it omitted any enforcement mechanisms. Donald Trump showcased his personal rapport with authoritarian counterparts, while Vladimir Putin leveraged the appearance to challenge Western isolation efforts. Meanwhile, host Xi Jinping utilized the venue to exhibit China's expanding international stature without jeopardizing Beijing's alliances across the global south.

Key points

  • The high-profile trilateral conference failed to generate actionable policy details, fall…: The high-profile trilateral conference failed to generate actionable policy details, falling well short of historic wartime precedent summits.
  • Each participating leader extracted individual domestic and international political lever…: Each participating leader extracted individual domestic and international political leverage despite the summit yielding only vague collective commitments.
  • Host nation China effectively leveraged the trilateral platform to signal a diplomatic pi…: Host nation China effectively leveraged the trilateral platform to signal a diplomatic pivot away from sole American global hegemony.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

It is arguably true, given it was the first such meeting of the leaders of China, Russia and the US, that Thursday’s gathering in Shenzhen deserved the description of “historic”.

But in terms of tangible outcomes, it is unlikely to warrant the “new page in the history of diplomacy” that Vladimir Putin claimed had been written, and will instead be consigned to a smallish footnote in any future volume of the 21st century.

It’s true that the meeting could yet be an icebreaker and the start of a permanent new dialogue. It’s also true that each leader can return home with something from the 90 minutes they spent together.

Despite falling asleep during the main Apec summit, Donald Trump had a chance to show his proximity to two authoritarian leaders he admires. With Ukraine having destroyed Russia’s bridge into Crimea, the US president greeted Putin not just as a friend but almost a wartime ally.

The Russian president, although occasionally pushed to one side by protocol during the early photo opportunities, will be able to show back home that it…

Politics