Other1 min read

National Academies report calls for faster decisions on publication retractions and corrections

By · Via STAT Health · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The expert panel, chaired by cell biologist Randy Scheckman, urges journals to conclude inquiries into questionable research within 12 weeks, extending to six months only for complex reviews. This framework addresses severe bottlenecks, as formal retractions currently take nearly 2.4 years on average despite over 5,000 papers being pulled globally in 2025. The committee also recommends tying research grants directly to misconduct compliance and requiring universities to disclose investigation outcomes publicly.

Key points

  • Researchers risk having their entire paper retracted if they fail to preserve the origina…: Researchers risk having their entire paper retracted if they fail to preserve the original underlying data.
  • Funding organizations should condition grant awards on an institution's adherence to stri…: Funding organizations should condition grant awards on an institution's adherence to strict research integrity standards.
  • Academic institutions need to publicly release findings from their internal research misc…: Academic institutions need to publicly release findings from their internal research misconduct investigations to protect the scientific record.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

In a report released on Thursday, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine urged the scientific community to respond more aggressively to claims of errors or manipulated data in published research, saying that papers containing findings that can no longer be trusted should be more swiftly corrected or retracted.

The report encouraged journals to complete editorial review of potentially problematic studies within 12 weeks, or within six months in more complex cases. The authors also stressed that study authors need to hold onto original data, adding that being unable to produce these records when concerns about a finding’s authenticity are raised could lead to a retraction. And the expert panel wrote that it is no longer “prudent” for researchers to argue against retraction of their work by asserting that flawed findings in one part of a study don’t impact the paper’s overall conclusions. That’s because issues with any part of a study can cast doubt on other findings.

The authors called on universities and other research institutions to respond more quickly and completely to research integrity inquiries, in part…

Other