Other1 min read

Missouri woman's $631k hostile workplace award upheld; exit damages face retrial

By · Via Times of India · Published by Everything Blog

In short

The Western District appeals court affirmed $131,000 in actual damages and $500,000 in punitive damages related to the hostile work environment Gassner experienced before her June 2018 resignation. She filed suit under the Missouri Human Rights Act after her schedule ballooned to 80 hours weekly for a minor 1.8 percent raise, even as African-American staff received significant pay hikes. While the liability findings stand, a retrial was mandated for constructive discharge damages because erroneous jury instructions improperly elevated the university's burden of proof concerning mitigation.

Key points

  • Lincoln University remains legally liable for subjecting Gassner to a racially hostile wo…: Lincoln University remains legally liable for subjecting Gassner to a racially hostile work environment, leaving the primary $631,000 financial penalty intact.
  • A new trial must take place specifically to recalculate damages for the constructive disc…: A new trial must take place specifically to recalculate damages for the constructive discharge claim due to flawed jury instructions.
  • The trial court erred by imposing an excessively high evidentiary standard on the univers…: The trial court erred by imposing an excessively high evidentiary standard on the university's defense that the plaintiff failed to mitigate her financial losses.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

A Missouri appeals court has upheld a jury's finding that Lincoln University subjected a former employee to a racially hostile work environment, while overturning the damages awarded on her separate constructive discharge claim and ordering a fresh trial limited to those damages.

The Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District, issued its ruling on November 17 in the case involving Sheila Gassner, a former university employee who alleged that she was discriminated against because she was white. The court affirmed the judgment in her favour on the hostile work environment claim but reversed the actual and punitive damages awarded for constructive discharge.

The case has been sent back to the circuit court for a new trial on damages related to the constructive discharge claim. The appeals court also granted Gassner's request for attorney fees incurred during the appeal.

Employee alleged excessive workload, unequal pay

Gassner joined Lincoln University in 1989 and became director of design and construction in 1999. In November 2013, after the university terminated its director of buildings and grounds, its president and chief of staff asked her to…

Other