Politics1 min read

Milburn’s absurdly ambitious report offers blueprint for fixing everything and everyone

By · Via The Guardian Politics · Published by Everything Blog

In short

Alan Milburn's policy document, titled *From a Welfare State to a Working State*, sets goals to double youth apprenticeships, deploy specialist advisers, and mandate that employers respond to applications. It also restructures financial support by drastically lowering monthly disability payments for young out-of-work claimants and imposing sanctions for non-participation. Poverty campaigners, including the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, caution that withdrawing financial aid harms mental health rather than helping people find work.

Key points

  • The ambitious recommendations would overhaul social security by replacing passive benefit…: The ambitious recommendations would overhaul social security by replacing passive benefit distributions with mandatory work engagement.
  • Anti-poverty advocates warn that steep benefit reductions will deepen poverty without imp…: Anti-poverty advocates warn that steep benefit reductions will deepen poverty without improving job prospects for vulnerable youth.
  • Political friction is anticipated as the Labour government navigates backbench reactions…: Political friction is anticipated as the Labour government navigates backbench reactions to substantial welfare spending cuts.

Sources checked by our analysis pipeline: 1

It is not clear if too many people were expecting Everything Everywhere All at Once, but that is what Alan Milburn has delivered. From a Welfare State to a Working State is almost absurdly ambitious. The terms of reference said something about the drivers of youth labour markets. We got a blueprint for how to fix everything and everyone.

What Keir Starmer, who commissioned it, had in mind, we’ll never know, but Milburn has taken up with gusto Andy Burnham’s general invocation to think boldly and rewire the state. Yes, it’s about training and jobs, but it’s also about pulling apart the NHS, giving schools and colleges an MOT, and once again, blowing up old-fashioned social security.

It is nothing less, Milburn suggests boldly, than rescuing an abandoned generation and giving their lives “shape and meaning”. It is about strategy, planning – making sure all kids are school ready by the age of five, as well as job ready by 18 – but it is also across the finer detail: he asks bosses at one point, for example, if they…

Politics